Defining ourselves in opposition to an idea
- nwatsonjones
- Aug 22, 2025
- 2 min read
Updated: Feb 10
I've been trying to work out how to define the concept of Self-Directed Learning positively, using affirmative statements rather than just placing myself in opposition to traditional schooling, but while I was struggling with this concept, I rediscovered this table from Ian Cunningham's "Self Managed Learning and the New Educational Paradigm" and I think it does a really good job of explaining it!
Traditional Schooling | Self Managed Learning |
Learning is organised by institutions such as schools and colleges | Learning can happen anywhere and not always in an organised setting |
Young people have to be controlled, otherwise they won't learn. Extrinsic motivation is required. | Young people naturally want to learn given the right support. Intrinsic motivation works. |
Imposed content curriculum | Free - no imposition |
Teacher is in charge | Learner is in charge, they work with an adult when they choose to |
Imposed timetable which pupils must follow | No imposed timetable - students learn as and when they choose |
Decisions made hierarchically | Joint decision-making between young people and adults |
Teachers impose tests | Young people choose if they want to take tests |
Formal relationships between teachers and students | Informal relationships, all on first name terms |
Dress code or uniform | No dress code or uniform |
Students required to be in fixed rooms. No access to toilets or refreshments without permission from teachers | The "rule of two feet" students permitted to go wherever they like on the site. |
Learning is preparation for life, so at some point, learning stops and life starts | Learning occurs from birth to death |
People who can memorise lots of facts are better than people who can't | Everyone is important and can contribute in different ways to their community |
Homework is required | Learning can occur anywhere and there is no compulsory homework |




Comments